I heard about this shortly after it happened as well, and like everyone else here, I was completely crushed. Gary's voice held such a deep, palpable sense of nostalgia for me, as it did for all the other SQ fans who cared nerdishly deeply about the Wilco universe. I can't help but ponder, though, if it wasn't something more than just his voice being connected to the game that was the magical thing about it for me personally. Honestly, and this sounds cheesy as hell, but I think it is true: the man's voice seems almost to invoke nostalgia in general. It has such a cult classical cultural resonance that the feeling of nostalgia is conjured abstractly and with no underlying memory necessary. In fact, I distinctly remember hearing his voice for the first time in SQ when I was a teenager and feeling nostalgia even then... about the game I was playing for the first time. What I'm trying to say is... well... the man was a paradoxical space-time-wizard-scion-messiah from the future-parallela-past, and the number of those type of folk is limited to 1. So no, replacing him isn't really possibly. Honestly, my personal opinion is that, in light of his passing, the best way to go about it would be not to try to recapture the magic. Rather, to cast the relaunch with the semi-sorta-alternate-wilcoverse-but-not-really-but-sorta with an iconic voice that is of a completely different variety. Let Gary be the omniscient Overvoice of the old timey temporal "feels" sorcery, and get someone with a completely different flavor to which we can make new nostalgic memories instead of trying to recapture the old. Just one humble nerd's opinion. If you open up that door, the possibilities for hilarity are still pretty endless. Heck, I could see enjoying the whole thing being narrated in a more "The Big Lebowski" style, even.